Closing attorney vs. title company in a Tennessee FSBO sale

This guide is general information for Middle Tennessee, not legal, financial, tax, or pricing advice, and not a substitute for your own attorney, appraiser, or tax professional. Laws, fees, and market conditions change; verify anything that matters to your sale with a licensed professional before relying on it.

The question every FSBO seller in Nashville eventually asks: "Okay, we have a buyer. Now who does the actual closing?"

In some states, a lawyer must run every real estate closing. In others, title companies do it all. Tennessee is a hybrid: closings are handled by either a closing attorney or a title company, and in the Nashville area, title companies (many of them attorney-owned or attorney-supervised) run most of them. Neither one is optional. Someone has to search the title, hold the earnest money, prepare the deed, coordinate the buyer's lender, and record the sale. Without an agent, that someone is chosen by you and the buyer.

Here's what they do, what it costs, and how to pick one.

What the closing agent actually does

Whether it's a law firm or a title company, the closing agent handles the same core jobs:

1. Title search. Checks the county records to confirm you own the property free of liens, judgments, unpaid taxes, or old mortgages that were never released. In Davidson County this means a search of the Register of Deeds records going back decades.
2. Title insurance. Issues a policy protecting the buyer (and the buyer's lender) against title problems the search missed. In Tennessee, the seller often pays for the owner's policy; the buyer pays for the lender's policy. This is negotiable.
3. Escrow. Holds the buyer's earnest money deposit from contract to closing. This is why earnest money never goes to the seller: it sits with the closing agent, and the contract says who gets it if the deal falls through.
4. Prepares the closing documents. The deed (usually a warranty deed in Tennessee), the settlement statement showing every dollar in and out, the transfer tax forms, and the affidavits both sides sign.
5. Coordinates the buyer's lender. If there's a mortgage, the closing agent receives the loan documents, makes sure the lender's conditions are met, and receives the funds.
6. Runs the closing. Both sides sign, usually at the closing agent's office. In Tennessee, buyer and seller often sign separately.
7. Disburses and records. Pays off your mortgage from the proceeds, pays the county recording fees and transfer tax, wires you the balance, and records the deed with the county. The sale isn't final until the deed is recorded.

What a closing attorney does that a title company doesn't

A closing attorney can also advise you. A title company is a neutral party; it processes the transaction but doesn't represent either side. An attorney can review your purchase agreement before you sign it, explain what a contingency means for you, draft an addendum when the buyer's inspection turns up a problem, and tell you whether an unusual request from the buyer is normal.

For a FSBO seller with no agent, that advice is the piece that's otherwise missing from the deal. Many Nashville sellers use a title company for the closing itself and pay an attorney separately for an hour or two of contract review. Others use a law firm that does both.

What it costs in Nashville

Costs vary by firm, by deal, and over time. These are ranges Nashville sellers have commonly seen; treat them as a starting point for your own quotes, not as a price list:

Item	Typical range	Who usually pays
Closing / settlement fee	$500–$1,000	Split, or negotiated
Title search	$150–$300	Often seller
Owner's title insurance policy	Based on sale price; roughly $1,000–$2,000 on a $450,000 home	Often seller (negotiable)
Lender's title policy	Smaller, roughly $300–$600	Buyer
Deed preparation	$100–$250	Seller
Tennessee transfer tax	Set by state law (currently $0.37 per $100 of sale price; verify the current rate)	Buyer, by custom
Recording fees	$50–$150	Buyer
Attorney contract review (optional, separate)	$300–$800 flat, or $250–$400/hour	Whoever hires them

Two things to know:

• "Who pays" is custom, not law. In Middle Tennessee, sellers customarily pay for the owner's title policy and deed prep; buyers customarily pay the transfer tax and recording fees. Every one of these can be shifted in the purchase agreement. Buyers sometimes ask sellers to cover closing costs as part of an offer; that's a price negotiation wearing a different hat.
• Get a written quote before you sign anything. Any closing agent will give you an estimated settlement statement for a hypothetical sale price. Ask two of them. The fees are more competitive than most sellers realize.

Attorney or title company: how to choose

For most straightforward FSBO sales, either works. Lean toward an attorney (or an attorney-owned title company) if:

• It's your first sale without an agent and you want someone who can answer "is this normal?"
• The property has any complication: an estate, a divorce, a co-owner who's hard to reach, a boundary question, an old lien, a well or septic, an HOA with transfer rules.
• The buyer has an agent and you don't. An attorney evens the table.

Lean toward a title company if:

• The deal is simple, you've read the contract carefully, and cost is the priority.
• The buyer's lender or the buyer prefers a specific title company and you're comfortable with them.

Whichever you choose, pick them before you have an offer, not after. A closing agent lined up in advance can send you the standard purchase agreement, explain the timeline, and answer the buyer's first questions on day one. Scrambling to find one after an offer arrives costs you days and leverage.

The Tennessee-specific things to ask about

• The purchase agreement. Your closing attorney or title company can provide a purchase agreement appropriate for a Tennessee residential sale. Never accept a handwritten or homemade contract, and have an attorney review any contract before you sign it.
• The Residential Property Condition Disclosure. Tennessee requires it from most sellers. Your closing agent will expect a signed copy in the file. Read our disclosure guide.
• Lead-based paint disclosure if the home was built before 1978, which covers much of Nashville's housing stock.
• Wire fraud. Closings are the number-one target for wire fraud in the country. Your closing agent will give you wiring instructions for your proceeds; confirm them by phone with a number you already have, never by replying to an email. Legitimate closing agents will never change wiring instructions by email at the last minute.
• Signing separately. Ask whether buyer and seller sign together or separately. In Nashville, separate signings are common and are often easier for FSBO sellers.

Timeline: contract to keys

A typical Tennessee closing with a financed buyer takes 30–45 days from signed contract. The closing agent's work runs in the background:

• Week 1: earnest money deposited, title search ordered.
• Weeks 1–2: buyer's inspection period (usually 7–10 days per the contract).
• Weeks 2–4: appraisal, lender underwriting, title commitment issued, any title issues cleared.
• Final week: settlement statement drafted, your payoff confirmed with your lender, closing scheduled, buyer's final walkthrough.
• Closing day: sign, funds disburse, deed records. Proceeds typically wire same day or next business day.

A cash buyer can close in 10–14 days if the title is clean.

Find a closing attorney or title company

Nashville Buys lists closing attorneys and title companies who work with for-sale-by-owner transactions. Each profile shows their service area and starting fees, and you contact them directly. Lining one up is step 16 on our 37-step FSBO checklist.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a lawyer to sell my house in Tennessee? Not by law. Tennessee permits title companies to conduct closings; confirm current requirements with a licensed closing agent. But someone licensed has to handle title, escrow, and recording, and many FSBO sellers choose an attorney precisely because there's no agent to explain the contract.

How much are seller closing costs in Tennessee? For a FSBO sale, often in the range of 1–2% of the sale price, mostly title insurance, the closing fee, and deed prep, plus any concessions you agree to. That's compared with 5–6% when agent commissions are added. Get an estimated settlement statement from a closing agent for an exact number.

Who pays the transfer tax in Tennessee? By custom in Middle Tennessee, the buyer pays the state transfer tax (currently $0.37 per $100 of price; verify the rate at closing). Like every closing cost, it can be negotiated in the contract.

Can the buyer and I use the same closing attorney? The closing agent is a neutral party handling the transaction, and it's normal for both sides to close through the same one. If you want someone representing your interests specifically, that's a separate attorney engagement, usually a flat fee for contract review.

Where does the earnest money go? To the closing attorney's or title company's escrow account, never to the seller. If a buyer offers to give you a deposit directly, decline and refer them to the closing agent.

---

Nashville Buys connects sellers with independent professionals. We are not a broker, attorney, appraiser, lender, or title company, and nothing on this site is advice for your specific situation. Every sale is different. Hire your own attorney.